Home/Case studies/packageVUE

Case study · packageVUE · How to deliver

Every label scored well. Forced choice found the one people wanted.

A craft beverage brand was launching a new product made with a well-known partner. It had four strong label designs and room for one.

Client

Craft beverage brand, new partnership product

We worked with

The brand team

The decision

Which of four label designs to launch, and what to change on it

When

Before launch

37%ranked Design C first, more than any other design, and few ranked it last
9 or 10out of 10 on the key measures for all four designs, so scores alone could not pick a winner
32%ranked the most polarizing design last, even though many ranked it first

The challenge

Four strong labels for a new product, and room for only one.

The client was launching a new craft product made with a well-known partner. Its designers had four label options, each with a different look, and the label had to do two jobs: stand out among established brands and explain a product people had never tried.

The team needed to know which label would sell, how it would hold up on a crowded shelf, and what to fix before launch.

What we did

Put each label on a shelf, then made people choose.

A packageVUE study with 454 regular category buyers nationally, plus a boost in the partner's home market. Each person saw a simulated shelf of 15 products four times, with one new label each time, and picked what they would want. They then rated two of the four labels in depth against Quest target scores, ranked all four, and marked what they liked, disliked or found confusing on each label.

Method. packageVUE label test. 454 target buyers nationally plus a home-market boost. A simulated shelf of 15 products, monadic sequential rating against Quest targets, a forced ranking, a highlighter exercise and open-ended questions on missing information.

The decision

Launch Design C, and add the information people asked for.

All four labels scored 9 or 10 out of 10 on the key measures, so scores alone could not separate them. The forced ranking did. Design C was ranked first by 37%, and it was the top choice in nearly every subgroup. Design D was the most polarizing: it drew many first-place votes, but even more last-place ones. Design A, the strongest on ratings in the partner's home market, fell to the bottom when people had to choose.

Design C was one of the two labels that stood out most on the shelf, and it left the fewest people wanting more information. Across all four labels, people asked for the same things: what it tastes like, how strong it is, where it is made, and more about the partner. Those became the changes to make before launch.

Design C won the ranking, and few ranked it last.

The result

The recommended label, refined by the research.

The client launched the recommended label, with some modifications based on the research.

Design C stood out and left the fewest questions.

What they walked away with

An answer the team could act on.

  • A clear winning label, backed by forced choice
  • Shelf impact for each design among real competitors
  • A heat map of what people liked and disliked on each label
  • The information to add before launch

Client details withheld at the client's request. Result as reported by the client.