Home/Case studies/packageVUE

Case study · packageVUE · How to deliver

Shoppers liked one pack and noticed another. The combined pack lifted sales.

A home cleaning products brand had four new package designs and a brand most shoppers had not noticed. It needed the pack people would buy and the pack they would see.

Client

Home cleaning products brand

We worked with

The brand and marketing team

The decision

Which of four package designs to take to market

When

Ahead of a packaging redesign

43%ranked Pack A first to buy, twice the next design
63%recalled the brand on a crowded shelf with Pack C, ahead of the preferred design
9 of 10Quest package score for Pack A, well ahead of the other designs

The challenge

Four new package designs, and a brand few shoppers knew.

The brand was redesigning its packaging for a busy aisle full of household names. Only about a third of the shoppers it wanted knew the brand at all. The team had four designs and needed to know which would make people want to buy, and which would make the brand stand out on the shelf.

Those are two different jobs. A pack people like up close can still disappear next to the competition.

What we did

Tested every pack up close and on a crowded shelf.

Engaged home cleaners, the brand's target, first saw one design on a shelf among competing products and were asked which brands they remembered. They then rated all four designs against Quest's benchmarks for relevance, appeal, purchase intent, uniqueness and solving a problem, plus fit to the category and the brand and ten perceptions such as professional quality and confidence in the result. Finally, they ranked the four by which they would buy first.

Method. packageVUE package test. 493 engaged home cleaners who choose the products their household uses. Four designs, about 123 per design on the competitive shelf. Six measures against Quest target benchmarks, fit to category and brand, ten package perceptions and a purchase ranking. Online, about 15 minutes, fielded over five days.

The decision

Take Pack A, and give it the branding shoppers noticed on Pack C.

Pack A won almost everything. It scored significantly higher than all three alternatives on appeal, purchase intent, solving a problem, and fit to both the category and the brand, and on seven of ten perceptions, including professional quality and confidence in the result. It earned the top package score, and it was ranked first to buy about twice as often as the next design.

It did not win on the shelf. With Pack C, 63% recalled the brand after seeing the competitive lineup, well ahead of Pack A. For a brand most shoppers did not yet know, being seen mattered as much as being liked. Quest recommended Pack A's design carrying Pack C's branding.

Pack A led on every measure that drives purchase.

Top-two-box share of all 493 respondents.

The result

The client launched the combined pack, and sales rose sharply.

The client combined the two designs as Quest recommended, and sales have risen sharply in market since, as reported by the client. The team had gone in with a clear winner, the specific branding change to make it stand out on the shelf, and a read on the perceptions the new pack had to deliver: professional quality and confidence in the result.

The pack people would buy was not the one they noticed. The recommendation used both.

What they walked away with

An answer the team could act on.

  • A scorecard for all four designs against Quest benchmarks
  • Brand recall for each design on a competitive shelf
  • Ten package perceptions, design by design
  • A recommended design with one specific change

Client details withheld at the client's request. Result as reported by the client.