Home/Case studies/positioningVUE
Case study · positioningVUE · What to build
One positioning won with 55%, and the product has thrived in market.
A consumer health brand needed to decide which of three brand positionings to launch a new product with.
Consumer health brand, new supplement
The brand team
Which of three brand positionings to launch a new product with
Before launch
The challenge
A new product built on unfamiliar science, and three ways to introduce it.
The brand had a new health supplement built on science most shoppers had not heard of. The team had three brand positionings: one led with a search for answers, one with the problem to beat, and one with overall wellness. It needed to know which would carry the product into market.
Believability was the risk. A product asking people to accept new science needs a positioning that makes the claim feel credible, not just appealing.
What we did
Scored each positioning in depth, then asked people to choose between all three.
Each respondent evaluated one positioning in depth against Quest's target benchmarks for relevance, appeal, motivation, believability, uniqueness and solving a problem. They rated the headline, the benefit statement and the other elements separately, and highlighted the words they liked and the words that confused them. Then they saw all three positionings and picked a favorite. Results were read for the total and for each audience, from daily users of the category to people who had never tried it.
Method. positioningVUE positioning test. 680 adults who use or are open to the category. Three positionings, about 225 respondents each in depth. Six measures against Quest target benchmarks. Element-level appeal. Word highlighting. Head-to-head preference. Online, fielded over one week.
The decision
Launch with the wellness-led positioning, and aim it at engaged users first.
Rated on their own, all three positionings performed well, and none ran away with the scorecard. Side by side, the wellness-led one was the clear favorite: 55% chose it, and it won with every audience, whichever positioning people had first evaluated in depth. It was also the only one where every element worked: its headline was significantly more appealing than both others, and its benefit statement significantly more appealing than one of them.
It also had the highest believability of the three, the product's weakest point overall. Among daily users of the category, purchase intent was significantly above both alternatives. Quest recommended it as the launch positioning, with marketing focused first on engaged users.
The result
The client launched with it, and the product has been highly successful.
The client went with Quest's recommendation, and the product has gone on to be highly successful in market, as reported by the client. The team had taken into launch a positioning chosen on evidence, element-level guidance on the headline and benefit, the words to change to make the science easier to believe, and a clear view of which audiences to reach first.
What they walked away with
An answer the team could act on.
- A scorecard for each positioning against Quest benchmarks
- Head-to-head preference, by audience
- Element-level guidance on the headline and benefit
- The words to keep and the words to fix
Client details withheld at the client's request. Result as reported by the client.