Home/Case studies/productVUE

Case study · productVUE · How to deliver

The added feature did not earn its place. The simpler version did just as well.

A pet care brand needed to decide which version of a new pet product to launch, and what to say on the pack.

Client

Pet care brand

We worked with

The marketing and innovation team

The decision

Which version of a new pet product to launch, and what to say on the pack

When

Before launch

42%of owners with the added feature never noticed it working, few relied on it
2 in 3would choose the new product over their current brand after a week, steady from first look to after use
+12 ptsrise in "extremely good value" once owners had used it, with the simpler version

The challenge

A promising new pet product, and a feature that would add cost and clutter.

The brand had a new pet product ready for testing in two versions. One carried an added feature; the other did not. The feature would add cost and take space on the pack.

The team needed to know whether owners would switch from the brand they already used, whether the feature mattered, and which claims to put on the pack.

What we did

Put both versions in homes for a week and compared them side by side.

Owners who used a leading competitor read a description of the product and rated it. Each was then sent one of the two versions to use at home for a week under set instructions, and rated it again afterward: purchase intent, appeal, value, uniqueness, whether it solved a problem, whether it beat their expectations, and how much they relied on the feature. Comparing first look with real use showed which promises the product kept.

Method. productVUE in-home use test. 441 owners rated the concept; 273 used a product at home for a week and rated it again. Two versions, each owner received one. Before and after measures, attribute expectations, feature reliance. Online surveys.

The decision

Launch the simpler version and spend the pack on what owners valued.

The two versions performed alike. After a week, the difference on purchase intent, appeal, value, uniqueness and solving a problem was not statistically significant. The feature itself barely registered: many owners who had it never noticed it working, few relied on it, and it ranked sixth of seven when owners named the most helpful attributes.

What owners did value were two core benefits: about two in three said the product beat their expectations on its two core benefits. Quest recommended launching without the feature, leaving the pack free to lead with those two benefits.

After a week of real use, the two versions were statistically the same.
With the added featureSimpler versionWould buyAppealingUniqueWould choose over current brandSolves a problemGood valueTop-2 box after a week at home; about 135 owners per version. No difference shown is statistically significant.

The result

The product launched, positioned on what owners valued.

The client used the results to continue work on the product's positioning and ultimately launched it, with other added benefits, as reported by the client. The study gave that work its starting point: the claims owners proved for themselves at home, and a clear read on switching, with two in three owners choosing the new product over their current brand both before and after trying it.

Owners valued the core benefits. The added feature came sixth.
Benefit ABenefit BBenefit CBenefit DBenefit EThe added featureBenefit FMost helpful attributes, owners who used the version with the feature (142). More than one answer allowed.

What they walked away with

An answer the team could act on.

  • The version to launch, with the evidence to drop the feature
  • Pack claims owners confirmed at home
  • Switching intent from a leading competitor, before and after use
  • Where the product beat expectations, and where it fell short

Client details withheld at the client's request. Result as reported by the client.